So, I stumbled across a new place out on East Washington, not too far from I-465.
By and large, the price points of the items in this place beats out Indy Army Navy. They are an off-shoot of Pop Guns right down the street and they were running out of room for their surplus and supply spot, so they opened up a new place. That new place had a lot of issues and now they reside a bit further down the street from Pop Guns.
The actually reside where Sly Fox Powersports used to be, 8250 E. Washington Street.
They have lots of new and used stuff, and they plan on adding more to their current selection. More importantly, they're working on getting an online shop set up so you can order things from them with no shipping charge. I was told that directly from the owner himself.
If you have a chance, check them out. I'll definitely be going back and this may be my go-to spot for some or most of my gear.